The Laurel Vs. Yanny Booktag

Once every while, there is something new on the internet that splits people into teams! Then the memes begin and you start seeing it everywhere. Those things usually have a level of controversy (Either good or bad) and the latest of those is the Laurel Vs. Yanny audio file!

If you haven’t heard of this (As if!) or you want to understand the science behind it, then you can find the best explanation here:

https://youtu.be/yDiXQl7grPQ

I can actually hear both words depending on what I concentrate on, but many people hear only one of those.

So this book tag is inspired by the idea that we see (or hear) things in different ways. And I occasionally see this in the book world, there are books that some people love while other can’t stand . Here are some of the most controversial books that I saw during my reading life:

🌟 Classics:

82bd866d86c954622a71c99dd36421e5

I do believe that readers have a love or hate relationship with Classics and not so much in between. I belong to the later group as I rarely enjoy Classics, but some people find a kind of magic in those books and they adore them. I think my problem with those is that they tend to be slow and over-descriptive, a combination that I will never tolerate.

🌟 Shatter Me series

x500
I remember the first time seeing this in a bookstore and I was not a bookworm yet, so I couldn’t tell who is Tahereh and what is this book about. I went to GR for help (obviously) and got confused even more! This has a decent rating but it had many mixed reviews due to two things – IΒ  believe :
* The writing style: Some found it magical and flowery and beautiful while others say that it heavily uses them and it becomes annoying and bad!

* The characters: This indeed has some annoying characters but I liked the development of the characters throughout the series, some couldn’t even continue book 1 so they don’t know this and I don’t blame them because Juliette is so stupid and childish in book 1.

I enjoyed the writing style and the character development, but Restore me demolished all of this and I sadly gave it 2 stars. So once again, I can understand both readers POV!

🌟  An Enchantment of Ravens

30969741
One thing that we won’t argue about is that this has a perfect cover, This was one of my most anticipated reads of the year and my most disappointing one. I read this as soon as it was released, back then it had an average rating of ~ 4.2 and I was pretty sure that there was something wrong with me, how can I not enjoy it when all those people can!
Did I read the same book? Did I miss something?
Anyway, I decided that I must be honest and gave this only 2 stars! More readers started reading this and gradually the rating started to drop. I started to see more 1 & 2 stars and reviews that I could relate to. So this is either a hit or miss, It didn’t work for me and many people (Average rating is now 3.65) but many enjoyed it too which is good for the author :D.
🌟 13 reasons why

410vkh0iwbl-_sx338_bo1204203200_
Since season 2 has just been released, I couldn’t help but to include this book on this list. I didn’t read the book but I watched the TV series and I liked it, I could actually relate to both Hannah and Clay. But if you check the GR page of this book you will see that it has a very good rating, look at the top reviews and they are mostly 1 or 2 stars! I can understand where this conflict comes from. Some say that it is a dangerous book/ series and that it encourage suicide, while others say that it is good to raise awareness surrounding this topic. I believe that it depends on the reader because people are not the same and that it can be both good/ bad, so I would recommend to read this with caution anyway!

🌟 The Black Witch

81w1vtfpdul
This was called the most controversial book of the year by many readers. This was the total opposite of An Enchantment of Ravens. As soon as it was released, there was this review that said this was racist and suddenly GR is in WW3! This started to get many 1 star ratings from people who didn’t even read it (What?!) and then there were some heroes (at least to the author) who read and reviewed this and surprisingly it started to get many 5 stars. Those reviews pointed out that it was not racist and that it had many strong points and people started interacting positively more and more. The average rating was ~2 but now it has an average rating of 3.8 stars. I haven’t read this yet so I can’t judge but hopefully will someday.

So what do yo hear: Laurel or Yanny?
what other prescriptions do you have? please share them in the comment section πŸ’™

 

8 Comments

  1. Did you just create this tag? I would love the chance to do it too!
    And the same thing happened to me with An Enchantment of Ravens. All the early reviews were raving about it and then I felt bad when I gave it two stars. And what happened to The Black Witch has happened to so many books and it’s so annoying. It happened to Carve the Mark and All the Crooked Saints and several others. There’s always one person who says they’re racist or somehow problematic and then everyone starts writing rant reviews without having even read them. Great post! And I’m so loving your blog!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I did but I was definitely new and did not know what I was doing (Still discovering), and thus consider yourself tagged! Yes, I prefer to judge myself because early reviews are mostly at the extremes of love/hate! I did try All the Crooked Saints and although I love Maggie and her writing style but that book was just not for me, I was to blame because I didn’t know it it magic realism which I hate! Thanks Angelica, your blog looks amazing too πŸ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s